| 1866 |
F.A.C. Macmanus |
1940 |
Charles Pink |
| 1867 |
J.A. Blackburn |
1941 |
Bill Steppon |
| 1868 |
J.A. Blackburn |
1942 |
George Harms |
| 1869 |
J.A. Blackburn |
1943 |
Don Robinson (did not serve - military call-up before season) |
| 1870 |
C.C. Smith |
1944 |
Howard Wikel (did not serve - military call-up before season) |
| 1871 |
J.A. Mercer |
1945 |
Don Lund |
| 1872 |
F.N. Wood |
1946 |
Bliss Bowman |
| 1873 |
George Winslow |
1947 |
Cliff Wise |
| 1874 |
Edgar Root |
1948 |
John Weisenburger |
| 1875 |
William Johnson |
1949 |
Harold Raymond |
| 1876 |
William Johnson |
1950 |
Bob Wolff |
| 1877 |
W. M. Thompson |
1951 |
Leo Koceski |
| 1878 |
W.M. Thompson |
1952 |
Bruce Haynam |
| 1879 |
Charles Hodges |
1953 |
Bill Mogk |
| 1880 |
F.W. Davenport |
1954 |
Jack Corbett |
| 1881 |
F.W. Davenport |
1955 |
Dan Cline |
| 1882 |
William Harvey |
1956 |
Moby Benedict |
| 1883 |
Charles Allmendinger |
1957 |
Ken Tippery |
| 1884 |
John Hibbard |
1958 |
None |
| 1885 |
John Hibbard |
1959 |
Jim Dickey |
| 1886 |
John Hibbard |
1960 |
Bill Roman |
| 1887 |
Lincoln McMillan |
1961 |
Richard Syring |
| 1888 |
George Codd |
1962 |
Ed Hood |
| 1889 |
George Codd |
1963 |
Joe Jones |
| 1890 |
George Codd |
1964 |
Dave Campbell |
| 1891 |
George Codd |
1965 |
Ted Sizemore |
| 1892 |
Thomas Robinson |
1966 |
Bob Gilhooley |
| 1893 |
Frank Crawford |
1967 |
None |
| 1894 |
Edmund Shields |
1968 |
Doug Nelson |
| 1895 |
Edmund Shields |
1969 |
Peter Titone |
| 1896 |
William Holmes, Charles Watkins |
1970 |
Tom Lundstedt |
| 1897 |
Guy Miller |
1971 |
Mark Carrow |
| 1898 |
John Butler |
1972 |
Pete Helt |
| 1899 |
Ernest Lunn |
1973 |
Pat Sullivan |
| 1900 |
Edwin McGinnis |
1974 |
John Lonchar |
| 1901 |
Edwin McGinnis |
1975 |
Craig Forhan |
| 1902 |
Jerome Utley |
1976 |
Dick Walterhouse |
| 1903 |
Jerome Utley |
1977 |
Ted Mahan, Mark Grenkoski |
| 1904 |
Curtis Redden |
1978 |
Jim Berra |
| 1905 |
Charles Campbell |
1979 |
Jim Capoferi |
| 1906 |
Roswell Wendell |
1980 |
George Foussianes |
| 1907 |
Chester Taft |
1981 |
Gerry Hool |
| 1908 |
D.R. Kennedy |
1982 |
Jim Paciorek, Greg Schulte |
| 1909 |
John Sullivan |
1983 |
Jeff Jacobson, Rich Bair |
| 1910 |
Clarence Enzenroth |
1984 |
Rich Bair, Chuck Froning, Gary Wayne |
| 1911 |
Norman Hill |
1985 |
C.J. Beshke, Ken Hayward |
| 1912 |
Elmer Mitchell |
1986 |
Casey Close, Scott Kamieniecki |
| 1913 |
Joseph Bell |
1987 |
Greg Everson, Mike Ignasiak |
| 1914 |
George Sisler |
1988 |
Mike Ignasiak |
| 1915 |
Edmund McQueen |
1989 |
Jim Durham, Dave Peralta |
| 1916 |
George Labadie |
1990 |
Phil Price, Kirt Ojala |
| 1917 |
None - No Team (World War I) |
1991 |
Mike Matheny, Dan Ruff |
| 1918 |
Burdette Glenn |
1992 |
Steve Buerkel, Todd Marion |
| 1919 |
Kenneth Knode |
1993 |
Todd Marion, Scott Timmerman |
| 1920 |
Vernon Parks |
1994 |
Kevin Crociata |
| 1921 |
Peter Van Boven |
1995 |
Rodney Goble, Ryan Van Oeveren |
| 1922 |
Henry Vick |
1996 |
None |
| 1923 |
Irwin Uteritz |
1997 |
Kirk Beermann |
| 1924 |
Jack Blott |
1998 |
Brian Kalczynski |
| 1925 |
George Dillman |
1999 |
Mike Cervenak, Bobby Scales |
| 1926 |
Steven Wilson |
2000 |
Rob Bobeda, Kevin Quinn, Bryce Ralston |
| 1927 |
William Puckelwartz |
2001 |
Nick Alexander, Bryce Ralston, Scott Tousa |
| 1928 |
Carl Loos |
2002 |
Bobby Korecky, Mike Sokol, Nate Wright, Joe Young |
| 1929 |
None |
2003 |
Jake Fox, Brock Koman, Mike Sokol |
| 1930 |
None |
2004 |
Brandon Roberts |
| 1931 |
Jack Tompkins |
2005 |
Kyle Bohm, Jim Brauer, Matt Butler, Michael Penn |
| 1932 |
Art Superko |
2006 |
Paul Hammond, Jeff Kunkel, A.J. Scheidt, Drew Taylor |
| 1933 |
Michael Diffley |
2007 |
Leif Mahler, Eric Rose |
| 1934 |
Avon Artz |
2008 |
Leif Mahler, Adam Abraham, Derek VanBuskirk |
| 1935 |
Russel Oliver |
2009 |
Kevin Cislo, Chris Fetter, Tim Kalczynski |
| 1936 |
Berger Larson |
2010 |
Chris Berset, Mike Dufek |
| 1937 |
Lyle Williams |
2011 |
Kolby Wood, Anthony Toth |
| 1938 |
Merle Kremer |
2012 |
Kolby Wood, John Lorenz, Brandon Sinnery, Patrick Biondi |
| 1939 |
Walter Peckinpaugh |
|
|
